The Best Eyebrow Pencils to Perfect Your Arches, According to Makeup Artists

Whoever said that eyebrows “make” the face was definitely onto something. Brows frame your features, which is why there’s so much emphasis on finding the best eyebrow pencil before any other brow product. Whether you want to exaggerate your arches (hello, foxy brows), clean up the shape by filling in sparse areas, or recreate the latest BeautyTok trend, a brow pencil is key to achieving your desired look.

Formulas and pencil tips vary widely, which is why we tapped celebrity makeup artists to share the eyebrow pencils they keep in their kits. If you’re a fan of feathery brows, you’ll want a pencil with a spoolie brush to blend out the product and give your brows that fluffy finish. For bigger and bolder arches, you might find yourself drawn to more pigmented and waxy formulas to get the job done. If all you need is some filling-in action, or just want a minimal, natural look, a straightforward pencil will probably do. 

Eyebrow trends come and go, but the best eyebrow pencils are forever—at least until you need to sharpen them. Shop 15 vetted picks, below.